A bar raiser is an experienced interviewer, from outside the team that is hiring, whose job in an interview loop is to protect the company's hiring standard. The term and the practice come from Amazon, which describes the purpose as helping each hire raise the performance bar for the company. Many fast-growing companies now run their own version, because the moment hiring speeds up is the moment the bar is most likely to slip.
This guide explains what a bar raiser does, what candidates can expect from a bar raiser interview, and how to set up a bar raiser programme of your own as hiring scales.
What is a bar raiser?
A bar raiser is an interviewer who is independent of the hiring team and is trained to judge candidates against the company-wide standard. Because they will not manage or work with the hire, and are not under pressure to fill the seat, they can focus on one question: is this person better than the people we already have in similar roles?
Amazon puts it this way: a new hire should bring skills and abilities that are "better than 50% of their would-be peers in similar roles". Amazon also says its Bar Raisers hire for the company as a whole, not for a specific team or role.
What does a bar raiser do?
Amazon describes three parts to the role.
| Role | What it involves |
|---|---|
| Interviewer | Interviews the candidate and assesses them against the company's core competencies, at Amazon its Leadership Principles |
| Decision driver | Leads the debrief and the group discussion, and makes the final hiring decision together with the hiring manager |
| Teacher and mentor | Coaches other interviewers and gives them feedback on their interviewing |
The third part is easy to overlook and probably the most valuable as a company grows. Bar raisers spread good interviewing habits across the organisation, one loop at a time.
Does a bar raiser have a veto?
Amazon's own description of the role does not use the word veto. It says the Bar Raiser and the hiring manager make the final decision together and that the Bar Raiser helps the group reach a decision. When you design your own programme, decide explicitly what happens when the bar raiser and the hiring manager disagree, and write it down.
Give your bar raisers evidence before the loop starts
Cohesyve sources candidates, tests them on AI simulations of the real work and returns a ranked shortlist, so every interviewer starts with the same evidence of what each person can do.
What is a bar raiser interview?
For a candidate, a bar raiser interview usually looks like any other interview in the loop. The interviewer may not say they are the bar raiser. The questions often probe judgement, ownership and how the candidate has handled difficult situations, and they may cover areas unrelated to the specific team.
At Amazon, interviews are built around its Leadership Principles, and candidates are encouraged to prepare examples using the STAR method (situation, task, action, result). Our guides to behavioural interview questions and the Amazon hiring process cover that preparation.
Why fast-growing companies use bar raisers
When a company is hiring slowly, the hiring manager knows the team well and has time to wait for the right person. When hiring speeds up, several things push the bar down at once.
- Deadline pressure. A manager with five open seats and a launch date is tempted to settle for whoever is available now.
- New interviewers. Many interviewers have just joined themselves and have no sense of the company standard.
- Team-by-team drift. Each team develops its own idea of good, and the company loses a shared bar.
A bar raiser counters all three. They are not under the team's deadline, they are trained and experienced, and they apply the same standard across teams.
How to set up a bar raiser programme
You do not need Amazon's scale to run a useful version. The steps below are a practical design for a company hiring tens or hundreds of people a year.
1. Decide where bar raisers are required
Start with the roles where a bad hire costs the most: senior hires, managers, and roles you hire in high volume, where one weak decision gets repeated. You can extend coverage later.
2. Choose the first group carefully
Pick people who are strong performers, good interviewers and respected across teams. Amazon describes its Bar Raisers as volunteers from many different roles, nominated by managers, peers or existing Bar Raisers. Avoid making it a seniority badge. Judgement and fairness matter more than job titles.
3. Train them
Amazon says its training takes anywhere from three months to a year, including shadowing veteran Bar Raisers over several interview cycles. A smaller company can compress it, but keep the same elements:
- Learn the company's competencies and the evidence that shows each one.
- Shadow several loops with an experienced bar raiser, then be shadowed.
- Practise running debriefs, including the hard ones where opinions split.
- Calibrate: score the same recorded or written answers and discuss differences.
Our guide to structured interviews covers the question and scoring design bar raisers should work from.
4. Define the decision rule
Write down how decisions are made. For example: the hiring manager and bar raiser decide together; if they disagree, the candidate is not hired, or the decision goes to a named senior leader. Ambiguity here causes more conflict than any other part of the programme.
5. Protect their time
Bar raising is extra work. Cap the number of loops per bar raiser per week, recognise the work in performance reviews, and rotate people out before they burn out.
6. Measure it
Track quality of hire and early attrition for loops with and without a bar raiser, and how often bar raisers and hiring managers disagree. See quality of hire metrics.
A worked example (illustrative)
A company plans to hire forty engineers and fifteen sales roles in a year. It picks six bar raisers from engineering, product, sales and operations, and runs a six-week training: two weeks on competencies and scoring, four weeks of shadowing. Every manager and senior hire gets a bar raiser in the loop. For volume roles, a bar raiser joins one loop in three and reviews debrief notes for the rest. Each quarter, the group compares the performance of hires with and without a bar raiser and adjusts coverage.
The numbers are invented. The structure is the point: a small trained group, clear coverage rules, a written decision rule, and a regular review.
Common mistakes
| Mistake | What happens | Fix |
|---|---|---|
| Too many bar raisers too soon | The standard dilutes | Start small, train properly |
| Bar raiser from the hiring team | No independence | Always from another team |
| No decision rule | Arguments after every loop | Write it down before the first loop |
| Bar raiser as a bottleneck | Hiring slows, managers route around it | Cap load, train more, cover the highest-risk roles first |
| Gut-feel interviewing | Bias with a title attached | Structured questions and a scorecard |
Bar raisers, hiring committees and evidence
A bar raiser is one way to separate the hiring decision from the pressure to fill a seat. A hiring committee review is another; some companies use both. Either works better when the people deciding have strong evidence in front of them. Cohesyve helps at that point: it tests candidates on AI simulations of the real work before interviews and returns a ranked shortlist, so the bar raiser and the hiring manager start from the same evidence of what each candidate can do.
Frequently asked questions
Is a bar raiser the same as a hiring manager?
No. The hiring manager owns the role and will manage the hire. The bar raiser comes from outside the team and represents the company-wide standard.
How do I know if my interviewer is the bar raiser?
Often you will not. Prepare for every interview in the loop in the same way.
Can a small company have bar raisers?
Yes. Even two or three trained interviewers from outside the hiring team, used for senior or high-volume roles, can keep the standard consistent while hiring grows.
How are bar raisers chosen at Amazon?
Amazon says they are nominated by managers, peers or existing Bar Raisers, and that they volunteer from many different roles before going through training.
What questions does a bar raiser ask?
Usually behavioural and judgement questions tied to the company's competencies, such as how the candidate handled a hard decision, a mistake or a conflict. See our behavioural interview questions.
