assessment centre

Assessment Centre: Exercises, Design and How to Run One

·6 min read
Assessment Centre: Exercises, Design and How to Run One

The short answer

An assessment centre (assessment center in US spelling) is a selection process, not a place: candidates complete several exercises, such as a group discussion, an in-tray task, a presentation and an interview, while trained assessors observe and score them against the same criteria. Done well it predicts job performance well, but it is expensive to build and run, so it suits graduate schemes, management roles and high-volume roles where the stakes justify it.

  • Pick four to six criteria from the job and design each exercise to show two or three of them.
  • Train assessors and have more than one assessor see each candidate.
  • Make decisions on the overall picture: CIPD research found competency-by-competency ratings unreliable.
  • Tell candidates what to expect and offer adjustments in advance.
For hiring teams

Cohesyve, which publishes this guide, runs online job simulations that can narrow a large applicant pool before the costly day.

An assessment centre is a structured selection event in which a group of candidates completes a series of job-related exercises, observed and scored by trained assessors against the same criteria. The US Office of Personnel Management puts it plainly: the assessment centre is not a place, nor a single process or method. It is a combination of methods, and that combination is what makes it work.

This guide is for employers deciding whether to run one, and how to design and run it well.

What is an assessment centre used for?

Assessment centres are used when you want strong evidence about people before an important decision and can afford the time to get it. OPM lists them as most often used for leadership, managerial, customer service and sales roles. In practice employers also use them for:

  • graduate and trainee schemes, where candidates have little work history to judge
  • promotion into first-line or senior management
  • high-volume hiring days, where several candidates are seen together
  • development centres, which use the same methods to plan training rather than to select

Is an assessment centre worth the cost?

The evidence for well-run assessment centres is good. OPM says overall assessment centre scores do a good job of predicting occupational success, and that candidates tend to see the process as fair and realistic. CIPD's summary of the research also says overall scores predict performance well.

The costs are real too. OPM notes that assessment centres are expensive to develop and run: they need several trained assessors, suitable space and regular updates because exercises become known. That is why many employers use cheaper online screening first and save the assessment centre for a shortlist.

Use an assessment centre whenConsider something lighter when
The role is senior, or the hire is a multi-year investmentThe role is junior with fast ramp-up
You have little work history to go on (graduates)Candidates have clear, checkable track records
You need to see behaviour with others (leadership, sales)The work is mainly individual
You can run it for several candidates at onceYou are hiring one person, occasionally
For hiring teams

Test candidates on the work itself

Cohesyve builds an AI job simulation of the role from your job description, finds and contacts candidates for it and returns a ranked shortlist. 14-day free trial for 10 candidates, not charged until it ends.

Assessment centre exercises

Choose exercises that resemble the job. Each one should show two or three of your criteria; together they should cover all of them at least twice.

ExerciseWhat it showsNotes
Group exercise (leaderless group discussion)Collaboration, influence, listening, problem-solving with othersOPM describes candidates solving problems together in a limited time
In-tray or e-tray exercisePrioritising, judgement, written communicationOPM's in-basket test simulates a pile of administrative tasks
Case study or analysis taskAnalysis, commercial sense, recommendationsUse data and a brief from your own business
PresentationStructuring an argument, clarity, handling questionsGive preparation time; assess content and delivery separately
Role playCustomer handling, coaching, negotiatingUse a trained role-player with a script
Structured interviewMotivation, past behaviour, specific skillsSame questions for everyone, scored on a rubric
Ability or skills testsNumerical, verbal or technical abilityOften taken online before the day

For more on individual exercises, see our guides to case study interviews and structured interviews.

How to design an assessment centre

1. Define what you are assessing

Start with a job analysis. List the four to six things that most separate good performance from poor in the role. Use your own competency or behaviour framework if you have one; the UK Civil Service's Success Profiles, for example, look at behaviours, strengths, ability, experience and technical skills.

2. Build an exercise matrix

Draw a grid with your criteria down the side and exercises across the top. Tick where each criterion will be observed. Aim for each criterion to appear in at least two exercises, and each exercise to cover no more than three.

3. Write the materials

Write candidate briefs, assessor guides and role-player scripts. Base scenarios on the real job. Keep the reading load proportionate: you are not testing reading speed unless the job needs it.

4. Write behavioural indicators and a rating scale

For each criterion in each exercise, describe what strong, acceptable and weak evidence looks like. A five-point scale with descriptions at each point works well. Our interview scoring rubric template can be adapted.

5. Train assessors

OPM says highly trained assessors are needed. Training should cover the criteria, the observe-record-classify-rate method, common rating errors, and practice scoring a recorded or role-played performance until assessors agree.

6. Pilot it

Run the exercises with current employees in the role. Fix timings, unclear briefs and exercises that do not separate strong from weak performers.

How to run the day

  • Brief candidates in advance: the schedule, the types of exercise, what to bring, and how to ask for adjustments.
  • Rotate assessors so each candidate is seen by several people across the day.
  • Record evidence, not impressions. Assessors write what the candidate said and did, then classify and rate it after the exercise.
  • Hold a wash-up meeting. Assessors discuss the evidence for each candidate, criterion by criterion, before agreeing an overall rating.
  • Decide on the overall picture. CIPD's research summary says competency-based ratings are unreliable on their own, while overall scores predict performance well. Use the criteria to structure evidence, and the overall rating to decide.
  • Give feedback. Candidates have given you a day; a short, specific summary of strengths and development points is a fair return.

Virtual assessment centres

Many employers now run assessment centres online. The same principles apply. Practical points:

  • test the video platform and breakout rooms beforehand, and have a backup plan
  • send materials in accessible formats, with clear timings
  • keep group exercises small enough that everyone can speak
  • use shared documents for in-tray and case exercises
  • allow for time zones when recruiting across countries

Fairness and adjustments

This is general information, not legal advice.

Ask every candidate before the day whether they need adjustments. In the UK, Acas lists job applicants among those employers must make reasonable adjustments for, and gives extra time on written or reading tests as an example. Common adjustments include extra time, rest breaks, accessible rooms, and materials in alternative formats. Monitor results by group after each centre, and look closely at any exercise where one group consistently scores lower.

Assessment centre checklist

  • [ ] Four to six criteria from a job analysis
  • [ ] Exercise matrix: each criterion seen at least twice
  • [ ] Exercises based on real work
  • [ ] Behavioural indicators and rating scale written
  • [ ] Assessors trained and calibrated
  • [ ] Exercises piloted with current staff
  • [ ] Candidates briefed and adjustments offered
  • [ ] Wash-up meeting held; decision on overall evidence
  • [ ] Feedback given to every candidate
  • [ ] Outcomes monitored by group

FAQs

What is the difference between an assessment centre and an assessment center?

None. "Assessment centre" is British spelling, used in the UK, India, Australia and much of the Commonwealth; "assessment center" is US spelling.

How long is an assessment centre?

It depends on the number of exercises. Many run for half a day or a full day; virtual centres are often split across shorter sessions. Keep it to what you need to see each criterion twice.

How many assessors do I need?

Enough that each candidate is observed by more than one assessor across the day, and no assessor is watching more candidates at once than they can record properly.

What is a development centre?

A development centre uses the same exercises and methods but aims to identify training needs for existing staff rather than to select. Make the purpose clear to participants, because it changes how they will approach it.

For hiring teams

See a job simulation built from your own job description

Cohesyve takes a job description, finds candidates, reaches out to them and runs an AI job simulation of the real work, then returns a ranked shortlist.

1,500+

assessments completed

50%

faster time-to-hire

5 min

from JD to assessment

14-day free trial · 10 candidates · Not charged until the trial ends

For job seekers

Taking a test like this yourself? Practise on AI job simulations of the real work. 3-day free trial, cancel anytime.

Practise group-day exercises on real work →

See Cohesyve in action

Free 30-min walkthrough

See it on your role