competency assessment

Competency Assessment: Methods, Examples and Rating Scale

·5 min read
Competency Assessment: Methods, Examples and Rating Scale

The short answer

A competency assessment measures whether a person shows the behaviours, skills and knowledge a role needs, judged against a defined set of competencies with clear descriptions of good and poor performance. In hiring, the strongest competency based assessments combine methods (structured interview questions about past behaviour, work samples and exercises) and score each piece of evidence on the same behaviourally anchored scale.

  • Derive a short list of competencies from a job analysis; five or six is plenty for one role.
  • Describe each competency with observable behaviours at each level of the rating scale.
  • Assess each competency with at least two methods, not interview answers alone.
  • Use competency ratings to structure evidence; CIPD research warns they are unreliable as stand-alone decisions.
For hiring teams

Cohesyve, which publishes this guide, turns a job description into job simulations scored against a rubric, which can sit alongside competency interviews.

A competency assessment is a structured way of judging whether someone has what a job needs, using a defined list of competencies and clear descriptions of what good looks like. A competency is usually a mix of behaviour, skill and knowledge: "communicates clearly", "manages stakeholders", "analyses data to make decisions".

In hiring, a competency based assessment replaces gut feel with a shared standard: every candidate is judged on the same competencies, using the same evidence-gathering methods and the same rating scale. The same approach is used for promotion, development and performance reviews.

What is a competency framework?

A competency framework is the list of competencies an organisation uses, with descriptions of each at different levels of seniority. Some organisations have one framework for everyone; others have role families with their own.

CIPD says competency frameworks, when done well, can increase clarity about performance expectations, and warns against an overly prescriptive and non-inclusive approach. In practice that means keeping the list short, writing behaviours that can actually be observed, and not penalising people for showing a competency in a different way from the person who wrote the framework.

The UK Civil Service's Success Profiles are a published example worth reading. They assess five elements: behaviours, strengths, ability, experience and technical skills, so behaviours sit alongside other kinds of evidence.

How to run a competency based assessment

1. Pick the competencies from the job

Start with a job analysis: what does the person actually do, and what separates strong performers from weak ones? The US Office of Personnel Management describes job analysis as the foundation for all assessment and selection decisions. Choose five or six competencies at most for one role. More than that and assessors spread their attention too thin.

2. Write behavioural indicators

For each competency, describe what you would see at each point on your rating scale. Indicators should be observable and specific to the role.

Example (illustrative): "Prioritises and organises work" for a team coordinator

RatingBehavioural indicator
5 StrongSets priorities from the team's goals, anticipates clashes, renegotiates deadlines early and explains the trade-offs
4Plans work in advance, adjusts when priorities change, keeps others informed
3 AcceptableCompletes work on time when priorities are clear; asks for help when they are not
2Works on tasks in the order they arrive; misses some deadlines without warning
1 WeakNo evidence of planning; relies on others to chase

3. Choose methods that show each competency

No single method shows everything. Map competencies to methods so each is seen at least twice.

MethodGood forWatch out for
Competency based interview (past behaviour)Judgement, collaboration, resiliencePolished storytellers can outscore better performers
Situational questions (what would you do)Judgement where candidates lack experienceShows what people know to say, not always what they do
Work sample or job simulationTechnical and task competenciesMust resemble the real work
Group exerciseInfluence, collaboration, listeningNeeds trained observers
PresentationCommunication, structuring an argumentAssess content and delivery separately
Ability or skills testNumerical, verbal, technical competenciesCheck it is pitched at the role's level

An assessment centre is a competency based assessment that combines several of these methods in one event, with trained assessors observing each candidate.

4. Write competency based interview questions

Ask for specific past examples, then probe. The Civil Service candidate guidance suggests candidates structure answers using STAR (situation, task, action, result), and interviewers can use the same structure to probe.

Examples (illustrative):

  • Prioritising: "Tell me about a week when you had more work than you could finish. What did you do first, and why?"
  • Stakeholder management: "Describe a time you had to get agreement from someone senior who disagreed with you."
  • Problem-solving: "Tell me about a problem at work where the obvious fix did not work. What did you try next?"
  • Learning: "What is something you had to learn quickly for a job? How did you go about it?"

Follow-ups: "What did you do, as opposed to the team?", "What would you do differently?", "How did you know it had worked?". Our STAR method guide and structured interview questions have more.

5. Rate evidence, then decide

Assessors should write down what the candidate said and did, then match it to the indicators and give a rating. Rate each competency separately, then discuss evidence with other assessors before agreeing an overall view.

Be careful how much weight the individual ratings carry. CIPD's summary of research on assessment centres says competency-based ratings are unreliable and should not be used on their own for selection, while overall scores predict performance well. Use the competencies to make sure you gather complete evidence, and make the decision on the overall picture.

For hiring teams

Test candidates on the work itself

Cohesyve builds an AI job simulation of the role from your job description, finds and contacts candidates for it and returns a ranked shortlist. 14-day free trial for 10 candidates, not charged until it ends.

Common pitfalls

  • Too many competencies. Ten competencies across a 45-minute interview means none is assessed properly.
  • Vague indicators. "Good communicator" cannot be rated consistently. "Explains a technical point so a non-specialist can act on it" can.
  • One method only. Interview answers measure how well someone describes their work. Pair them with something that shows the work.
  • Halo effect. One strong answer lifts every rating. Rate each competency from its own evidence.
  • Framework fit over job fit. A company-wide framework may not reflect what this role needs. Adapt it.
  • Untrained assessors. Run a short calibration session where assessors rate the same example and compare.

Competency assessment for current employees

The same method works for promotion and development: define the competencies for the next role, gather evidence from work, feedback and exercises, and rate against indicators. Make the purpose clear. People behave differently in an assessment that decides a promotion than in one that plans training.

Checklist

  • [ ] Competencies taken from a job analysis (five or six at most)
  • [ ] Behavioural indicators written for each rating point
  • [ ] Each competency assessed by at least two methods
  • [ ] Interview questions ask for specific past examples, with probes
  • [ ] Assessors trained and calibrated
  • [ ] Evidence recorded before ratings
  • [ ] Decision made on the overall evidence, not a sum of single ratings
  • [ ] Outcomes monitored for differences between groups

FAQs

What is the difference between competence and competency?

The terms are often used interchangeably. A common distinction is that competence refers to being able to do a task to a required standard, while a competency describes the behaviour behind effective performance. For hiring, what matters is that each item on your list is defined and observable.

Is a competency based interview the same as a behavioural interview?

Largely, yes. Both ask candidates for past examples of specific behaviours. "Competency based" signals that the questions map to a defined framework and are scored against indicators.

How many competencies should one interview cover?

Usually three or four, with two questions each and time to probe. Cover the rest through other methods.

For hiring teams

See a job simulation built from your own job description

Cohesyve takes a job description, finds candidates, reaches out to them and runs an AI job simulation of the real work, then returns a ranked shortlist.

1,500+

assessments completed

50%

faster time-to-hire

5 min

from JD to assessment

14-day free trial · 10 candidates · Not charged until the trial ends

For job seekers

Taking a test like this yourself? Practise on AI job simulations of the real work. 3-day free trial, cancel anytime.

Show your competencies on real work →

See Cohesyve in action

Free 30-min walkthrough

See it on your role