Job analysis is the systematic study of a job to find out what it involves and what it takes to do it well. It answers three questions: what does the person in this job do, what do they need to know and be able to do, and in what conditions?
It sounds like paperwork, but almost every people decision depends on it. The US Office of Personnel Management (OPM) describes job analysis as the foundation for all assessment and selection decisions. If you do not know what the job needs, you cannot write an accurate job description, choose a fair test or ask the right interview questions.
Why does job analysis matter?
A good job analysis gives you:
- Accurate job descriptions and adverts that attract the right people
- Assessment and interview criteria that relate to the work, which OPM notes supports the legal defensibility of selection procedures
- Training needs: the gap between what the job needs and what people have
- Pay and grading: a consistent basis for comparing jobs (job evaluation uses job analysis as its input)
- Performance standards that reflect the real job
- Workforce planning: a clear picture of the skills each role requires
In the US, the Uniform Guidelines on Employee Selection Procedures say that any validity study should be based on a review of information about the job, and a content validity study needs an analysis of the important work behaviours and work products. If you ever need to show that a test is job-related, the job analysis is your starting evidence.
Job analysis methods
Most job analyses combine two or three methods so that each covers the others' blind spots.
| Method | How it works | Strengths | Limits |
|---|---|---|---|
| Interviews | Structured conversations with job holders, managers and sometimes customers | Rich detail, uncovers judgement and context | Time-consuming; people describe the job as they see it |
| Questionnaires and surveys | Job holders rate tasks and skills for importance and frequency | Covers many people quickly; gives numbers to compare | Depends on a good task list; low response rates |
| Observation | An analyst watches the job being done | Sees what actually happens | Hard for knowledge work; people act differently when watched |
| Work diaries or logs | Job holders record what they do over a period | Captures real time spent | Effort for participants; can be incomplete |
| Subject matter expert (SME) panels | A group of experienced people agrees tasks and competencies | Fast consensus; good for new or changing jobs | Can reflect the views of the loudest |
| Critical incident technique | Collect examples of especially good and poor performance | Shows what separates good from poor | Takes skill to collect and code |
| Existing data | Review job descriptions, performance reviews, training materials, occupational databases such as O*NET | Quick starting point | May be out of date or generic |
O*NET OnLine, sponsored by the US Department of Labor's Employment and Training Administration, describes hundreds of occupations with task statements, skills, knowledge and work activities. It is a useful starting point anywhere in the world, as long as you adapt it to your organisation.
Hiring for a role right now?
Cohesyve takes a job description, finds candidates, reaches out to them and runs an AI job simulation of the real work, then returns a ranked shortlist. 14-day free trial for 10 candidates, not charged until it ends.
How to do a job analysis: step by step
1. Decide the purpose and scope
Are you writing a new job description, choosing a hiring test, regrading jobs or planning training? The purpose decides how deep you go. One role or a family of similar roles?
2. Gather existing information
Collect the current job description, adverts, performance objectives, training materials and any O*NET or industry profiles for the occupation.
3. Collect data from people who know the job
Interview two or three strong job holders and their manager, or run an SME workshop. If many people do the job, follow up with a short questionnaire.
Useful interview questions:
- Walk me through a typical week. What takes most of your time?
- Which tasks matter most to how well you are judged?
- What does someone new get wrong in their first three months?
- What separates the best people in this job from the rest?
- What do you need to know on day one, and what can be learned on the job?
- What tools, systems and working conditions are involved?
4. Build a task list and rate it
Write each task as a verb plus object plus purpose ("Reconciles supplier invoices against purchase orders to catch billing errors"). Ask SMEs to rate each for importance and frequency.
5. Identify the competencies behind the tasks
For each important task, list the knowledge, skills, abilities and behaviours needed. Note which are needed at entry and which can be trained.
6. Link tasks and competencies
OPM stresses the link between tasks and the competencies needed to perform them. A simple grid with tasks down the side and competencies across the top makes it visible, and shows which competencies matter most.
7. Document, review and sign off
Write it up, check it with the job holders and manager, and date it. Review it when the job changes.
Job analysis template
Copy and adapt:
JOB ANALYSIS Job title: Department: Analyst: Date: Purpose of analysis: (hiring / job description / grading / training) Sources used: (interviews with ..., questionnaire to ..., O*NET code ...)
1. Job purpose (one or two sentences)
2. Key tasks Task | Importance (1-5) | Frequency (daily/weekly/monthly) | % of time
3. Competencies Competency | Needed at entry? (Y/N) | Linked tasks
4. Working conditions Location, hours, travel, physical demands, tools and systems
5. Performance indicators How good performance is judged in this job
6. Reviewed and agreed by:
How to use the results in hiring
- Job description: turn the purpose and top tasks into the description. Our job description template and job description builder help.
- Selection criteria: pick the four to six competencies that are most important and needed at entry.
- Assessments: choose tests and tasks that measure those competencies. A work sample test built from the top tasks is a direct translation of the analysis.
- Interview questions: write one or two structured questions per competency. See our structured interview guide.
- Scorecard: use the competencies as the rows of your interview scorecard.
Common mistakes
- Describing the person, not the job. Analyse the role as it should be done, not the habits of the current holder.
- Relying on one source. A manager's view and a job holder's view often differ. Use both.
- Listing everything. A task list of 80 items hides the ten that matter.
- Never updating it. Jobs change with new tools and team structures.
FAQs
What is the difference between job analysis and job description?
Job analysis is the process of studying the job. The job description is one of the documents you write from it.
What is the difference between job analysis and job evaluation?
Job analysis describes what a job involves. Job evaluation uses that information to compare jobs with each other, usually to set grades or pay.
How long does a job analysis take?
It depends on the purpose. Updating a description for a familiar role can be done in a few interviews; analysing a job family to support a new testing programme takes much longer.
Who should carry out the job analysis?
Usually HR or a trained analyst, working with the hiring manager and people who currently do the job well.
