background check services

Background Check Services: How to Choose a Provider

·7 min read
Background Check Services: How to Choose a Provider

The short answer

Background check services are companies that verify a candidate’s history for an employer: identity, right to work, criminal records, employment and education, and sometimes credit or driving records. Choose one on the checks it can legally run in your countries, its compliance support, turnaround, data security and how it fits your hiring system. The legal rules differ sharply by country, so the provider should know the law where each candidate is based.

  • In the US, a third-party check is a consumer report under the FCRA: you need a standalone disclosure, written authorisation and pre-adverse and adverse action notices.
  • Many US states and cities restrict when you can ask about criminal history; California and New York City generally bar questions about criminal history before a job offer.
  • In the UK, criminal record checks go through DBS (England and Wales), with Basic, Standard and Enhanced levels.
  • In Australia, nationally coordinated criminal history checks come from the AFP or ACIC-accredited bodies; in Canada, from police services and RCMP-accredited fingerprinting companies.
  • Run checks only after consent, only for what the role needs, and ideally after a conditional offer.

Background check services, also called background check companies or employment screening companies, verify information about a candidate on an employer's behalf before a hire is confirmed. They collect consent, search records, contact past employers and schools, and send you a report. Used well, they confirm that the person you chose is who they say they are and can legally do the job. Used badly, they create legal risk and slow hiring down.

This guide covers what these companies do, the checks they run, how to choose one, and the legal frame in the US, UK, Australia and Canada. This is general information, not legal advice.

What does a background check company do?

A background check company gathers and verifies a candidate's records for an employer, usually after a conditional offer, and returns a report the employer uses to make the final hiring decision. A typical service includes:

  • collecting the candidate's consent and personal details through an online form;
  • verifying identity;
  • searching criminal record sources, or submitting the request to the official body that holds them;
  • contacting past employers and schools to confirm dates and qualifications;
  • handling disputes when a candidate says a record is wrong;
  • in the US, providing the notices the law requires.

The employer, not the provider, makes the hiring decision and remains responsible for using the results lawfully.

Types of background checks

CheckWhat it confirmsNotes
IdentityThe candidate is who they say they areUsually the first step
Right to workThe person can legally work in the countryRules are set nationally
Criminal recordConvictions (and sometimes other records)Strictly regulated in most countries
Employment historyEmployers, dates and job titlesDepends on past employers responding
Education and qualificationsDegrees, licences, certificationsProfessional registers for regulated roles
ReferencesPerformance and conduct from former managersSee our reference check form
CreditFinancial historyRestricted to certain roles in many places
Driving recordLicence status and motoring offencesFor roles that involve driving
Drug and alcohol testingSubstance useSeparate rules apply

Only run the checks the role genuinely needs. A data-entry role doesn't need a driving record check; a delivery driver does.

For hiring teams

Hiring for a role right now?

Cohesyve takes a job description, finds candidates, reaches out to them and runs an AI job simulation of the real work, then returns a ranked shortlist. 14-day free trial for 10 candidates, not charged until it ends.

How to choose a background check service

Use this checklist when you compare background check companies:

  1. Coverage. Can it run the checks you need in every country where you hire? For checks it can't run directly, does it go through the official channel (for example a DBS Responsible Organisation in the UK or an ACIC-accredited body in Australia)?
  2. Accreditation. In the US, the Professional Background Screening Association (PBSA) runs an accreditation programme and lists accredited firms on its site. Ask what accreditation or registration the provider holds in each country.
  3. Compliance support. Does it provide compliant consent forms, US FCRA disclosures and adverse action notices, and keep up with ban-the-box and fair chance rules?
  4. Consent and candidate experience. Is the consent flow clear and mobile-friendly? Can candidates see progress and dispute errors easily?
  5. Turnaround. How long does each check take, and what causes delays? Government checks often take longer than private searches.
  6. Accuracy and disputes. How does it confirm a record belongs to your candidate, and how fast does it resolve disputes?
  7. Data security and privacy. Where is data stored, who can see it, how long is it kept, and how is it deleted?
  8. Integrations. Does it connect to your applicant tracking system or HR system, so checks start automatically and results come back to the candidate record?
  9. International checks. For overseas candidates, which countries can it cover and how?
  10. Price. Pricing models vary (per check, per package, subscription). Ask for a quote based on your volume and check mix.

Ask for a sample report and test the candidate journey yourself before you sign.

Background check laws by country

United States: the FCRA

If you use a third-party company to run a background check, the report is a consumer report under the Fair Credit Reporting Act. The Federal Trade Commission sets out the employer's duties:

Before you get a report

  • Tell the candidate in writing that you may use the report for employment decisions. This disclosure must be a standalone document, not part of the application form.
  • Get the candidate's written authorisation. If you want it to cover their whole employment, say so clearly.
  • Certify to the background check company that you have done this, that you comply with the FCRA and that you won't discriminate.

Before you take adverse action (such as not hiring)

  • Give the candidate a pre-adverse action notice with a copy of the report and "A Summary of Your Rights Under the Fair Credit Reporting Act", so they can point out errors.

After you take adverse action

  • Tell the candidate the name, address and phone number of the background check company; that the company didn't make the decision and can't explain it; and that they can dispute inaccurate information and get a free copy of the report if they ask within 60 days.

When you are finished with the report, dispose of it securely. State laws can add more requirements. Our background check consent form is a starting point for the disclosure and authorisation.

United States: criminal records, ban-the-box and fair chance laws

The EEOC's guidance on arrest and conviction records says a blanket policy of excluding anyone with a record can breach Title VII if it disproportionately screens out a protected group and isn't job-related and consistent with business necessity. It recommends:

  • not treating an arrest as proof of conduct;
  • considering the nature and gravity of the offence, the time since it happened and the nature of the job;
  • giving the person a chance to explain (an individualised assessment);
  • not asking about convictions on application forms, or limiting questions to convictions relevant to the job.

Many states and cities go further with "ban-the-box" or fair chance laws. Two examples we checked:

LocationWhoRule
California (Fair Chance Act, since 1 January 2018)Employers with 5 or more employeesGenerally no questions about conviction history before a job offer
New York City (Fair Chance Act)Employers with 4 or more employeesNo criminal history inquiry until a conditional offer; written analysis and at least five business days to respond before withdrawing an offer

Check the rules in every state and city where you hire.

United Kingdom: DBS checks

In England and Wales, criminal record checks are issued by the Disclosure and Barring Service (DBS). Scotland and Northern Ireland have their own separate services.

DBS checkShowsHow to request
BasicUnspent convictions and conditional cautionsAny purpose; individual applies, or employer applies through a Responsible Organisation with consent
StandardSpent and unspent convictions and cautions from the Police National ComputerOnly for eligible roles, through a Registered Body
EnhancedAs Standard, plus relevant information police choose to discloseEligible roles such as work with children or adults, through a Registered Body
Enhanced with Barred List(s)As Enhanced, plus check of the children's and/or adults' barred listsMainly roles in regulated activity

Certificates go to the applicant, not the employer. You may only request a Standard or Enhanced check for a role that is eligible for that level.

Australia: national police checks

A nationally coordinated criminal history check can be obtained through the Australian Federal Police (which must be used for Commonwealth or ACT purposes) or through one of the bodies accredited by the Australian Criminal Intelligence Commission (ACIC). A check needs the person's consent. What it shows depends on the purpose of the check and on state and territory spent convictions laws, so some older or minor outcomes may not appear.

Canada: criminal record checks

The RCMP describes three main types: a name-based criminal record check; a fingerprint-based check, which is the most accurate way to confirm identity; and a vulnerable sector check for roles working with vulnerable people, which also looks for record suspensions for sexual offences. Private fingerprinting companies accredited by the RCMP can take fingerprints for civil purposes.

Other countries

Rules on criminal record checks, consent and data protection vary widely. Use a provider that runs checks through each country's official channels and can show you the legal basis for every check.

Good practice for any employer

  • Write a screening policy listing which checks apply to which roles, and why.
  • Check after a conditional offer wherever possible, so screening doesn't filter people out before you have assessed their skills.
  • Get informed consent and tell candidates what you will check.
  • Treat records individually. Look at relevance, seriousness and time since the offence; give the candidate a chance to respond.
  • Be consistent. Run the same checks for everyone in the same role.
  • Keep data only as long as you need it, then delete it securely.

Background checks confirm facts about a candidate's past. They don't tell you whether the person can do the job. Assess skills and fit first, with a fair, consistent process; see our structured interview guide and our guide to examples of discrimination in hiring.

Sources

Checked 30 October 2026.

For hiring teams

Bring one open role and see who Cohesyve finds

Cohesyve takes a job description, finds candidates, reaches out to them and runs an AI job simulation of the real work, then returns a ranked shortlist. You see who can do the work before you spend interview time on anyone.

1,500+

assessments completed

50%

faster time-to-hire

5 min

from JD to assessment

14-day free trial · 10 candidates · Not charged until the trial ends

For job seekers

Job hunting yourself? Practise on AI job simulations of the real work. 3-day free trial, cancel anytime.

Prove your skills before the checks begin →

See Cohesyve in action

Free 30-min walkthrough

See it on your role