Recruiting template

Self Appraisal Template

A self appraisal (self evaluation or self assessment) is the employee's own written review of their performance, sent to the manager before the review meeting. Send the form below with the guidance notes, so the meeting starts from the employee's view and both of you bring evidence.

Self Appraisal Template

Fill in your details

Every version below updates as you type. A field left empty stays as a [placeholder] in the text you copy.

Self appraisal form

When to use it: Sent to the employee one to two weeks before an annual or half-year review.

Self appraisal: [Employee name], [Job title] Period: [Review period] | Manager: [Manager name] Please return by [Return by]. We'll discuss it at your review on [Review meeting]. Rating scale: 1 Not yet meeting | 2 Partly meeting | 3 Meeting | 4 Exceeding | 5 Far exceeding 1. Objectives Objective | What I achieved (with evidence) | My rating [ ] | [ ] | [ ] [ ] | [ ] | [ ] [ ] | [ ] | [ ] 2. What am I most proud of this period, and why? [ ] 3. What was most challenging, and what did I learn from it? [ ] 4. Where did I fall short of what I wanted to achieve? What got in the way? [ ] 5. Which skills have I developed? Which do I want to develop next? [ ] 6. How have I contributed to the team and to our values? [ ] 7. What support would help me do my best work? (from my manager, team or the company) [ ] 8. What would I like to focus on next period? [ ] 9. Anything else I'd like to discuss? [ ]

Guidance note for employees

When to use it: Sent with the form so people know how to complete it.

How to complete your self appraisal - Look back over the whole period: your objectives, 1:1 notes, emails, feedback you received and work you delivered. It's easy to remember only the last few weeks. - Give specific examples. "I improved our help articles" is less useful than "I rewrote the ten most-viewed help articles, and tickets on those topics went down." - Be honest about what didn't go well and what got in the way. The review is a chance to fix obstacles, not a test. - Rate yourself against the scale descriptions, not against colleagues. - Keep it brief: a few sentences per question is enough. - It's your view. Your manager will share theirs at the meeting and you'll agree the final record together.

Short self evaluation (5 questions)

When to use it: Quarterly check-ins, probation reviews or teams that prefer a lighter process.

Self evaluation: [Employee name], [Review period] 1. What did I achieve that I'm pleased with? 2. What didn't go as planned, and why? 3. What did I learn? 4. What do I need from my manager or team? 5. What are my top priorities for the next period?

Self evaluation examples (illustrative)

When to use it: Showing employees what useful answers look like. All details are fictional; replace with real evidence.

Achievement "I led the move to the new helpdesk tool. I set up the macros and trained the team in two sessions, and we switched over without missing any customer replies." Teamwork "I paired with two new starters for their first month. Both now handle tickets independently, and one has taken over the billing queue." Communication "I started a weekly summary of top customer issues for the product team. They used it to prioritise two fixes this quarter." Problem solving "When integration tickets kept escalating, I wrote a troubleshooting checklist with an engineer. Most of those tickets are now resolved by our team." Area to improve "I said yes to too many side projects in Q3 and my response times slipped. I'd like to agree priorities with my manager each month." Development goal "I want to get better at handling difficult calls. I'd like to shadow the team lead on escalations and do the internal course."

How to use this template

  • 1Send the form and guidance note one to two weeks before the review meeting.
  • 2Remind employees of their objectives and where to find evidence, such as 1:1 notes.
  • 3Read the self appraisal before you write your own assessment, and note where you agree and differ.
  • 4Start the meeting by asking the employee to talk through their view.
  • 5Use differences in ratings as a discussion point, backed by examples on both sides.

Mistakes to avoid

  • Sending the form the day before the review.
  • Asking for a self appraisal and then not referring to it in the meeting.
  • Treating modest self-ratings as proof of low performance, or confident ones as arrogance.
  • Using a long form for a short quarterly check-in.
  • Questions that only invite praise or only invite criticism.

Questions

What is a self appraisal?

An employee's own written assessment of their performance, achievements, challenges and development needs, completed before a performance review. It is also called a self evaluation or self assessment.

What questions should be on a self appraisal form?

Progress against objectives, achievements, challenges and lessons, where they fell short and why, skills developed and to develop, contribution to the team, support needed and priorities for the next period.

How do I get useful self evaluations from my team?

Give people time and guidance, remind them of their objectives, ask for specific examples, and show that you read and use what they write.

Should self appraisals include a rating?

It can help to compare views, as long as both of you use the same scale descriptions. Some teams leave ratings out of the self appraisal to keep the focus on evidence.

What are good self assessment examples?

Ones that name a specific action and its result, such as the illustrative examples above. Vague statements such as "I worked hard" give the manager nothing to discuss.

For hiring teams

Before this form goes out, see who can do the work

Cohesyve takes a job description, finds candidates, reaches out to them and runs an AI job simulation of the real work, then returns a ranked shortlist.

1,500+

assessments completed

50%

faster time-to-hire

5 min

from JD to assessment

14-day free trial · 10 candidates · Not charged until the trial ends

See Cohesyve in action

Free 30-min walkthrough

See it on your role