Recruiting template

Performance Review Phrases and Appraisal Comments

Performance review phrases are starting points for the written comments in an appraisal. Pick the phrase that fits, then add a specific example and its effect; a phrase on its own is too general to be useful or fair.

Performance Review Phrases and Appraisal Comments

Fill in your details

Every version below updates as you type. A field left empty stays as a [placeholder] in the text you copy.

How to write a performance review comment

When to use it: The formula to turn any phrase below into a useful comment.

Formula: [Phrase] + [specific example] + [effect] + [next step, if any] Example (strength): [Employee first name] consistently delivers high-quality work. For example, [A specific example], and [The effect it had]. Next period, I'd like [Employee first name] to [A goal for next period]. Example (development): [Employee first name] would benefit from planning work further ahead. In Q3, two reports were late because priorities changed at short notice. Next period, we'll agree priorities monthly in our 1:1s. Checks before you finalise - Is every comment about the work and behaviour, not personality? - Does every comment have an example? - Would you write the same thing about someone else with the same evidence? - Have you avoided words that describe age, appearance, family status or other personal characteristics?

Quality of work and productivity

When to use it: Comments on output, accuracy and reliability.

Exceeding - Produces work that rarely needs correction and that others use as an example. - Spots problems before they reach customers and fixes the cause, not only the symptom. - Takes on extra work without the quality of core work slipping. - Sets a standard of accuracy the rest of the team has adopted. Meeting - Delivers accurate, complete work on time. - Checks their own work before passing it on. - Manages a full workload and flags early when deadlines are at risk. - Follows agreed processes and suggests improvements where they see them. Developing - Would benefit from checking work against the brief before submitting it. - Needs to flag risks to deadlines earlier, so plans can be changed. - Could reduce rework by asking clarifying questions at the start. - Is building speed; the next step is to keep accuracy while increasing volume.

Communication

When to use it: Comments on written, verbal and listening skills.

Exceeding - Explains complex topics clearly to people without specialist knowledge. - Writes updates that leaders use without editing. - Listens carefully and makes sure quieter colleagues are heard. - Handles difficult conversations calmly and constructively. Meeting - Keeps colleagues and stakeholders informed of progress and changes. - Writes clear, well-organised emails and documents. - Asks good questions to understand what others need. - Shares information in good time. Developing - Could make written updates shorter, leading with the main point. - Would benefit from checking understanding before ending a conversation. - Should share bad news earlier, so others can plan. - Is working on staying calm and focused in challenging meetings.

Teamwork and collaboration

When to use it: Comments on how someone works with others.

Exceeding - Helps colleagues without being asked, and shares credit generously. - Builds strong working relationships across teams. - Brings people together to solve shared problems. - Mentors newer colleagues, who become independent faster as a result. Meeting - Works well with colleagues and contributes in team discussions. - Is reliable: does what they say they will. - Shares knowledge when asked. - Respects others' views, including when they disagree. Developing - Could involve colleagues earlier in decisions that affect them. - Would benefit from offering help to teammates when they have capacity. - Should raise disagreements directly with the person concerned. - Is learning to balance their own priorities with the team's.

Problem solving and initiative

When to use it: Comments on judgement, ownership and improvement.

Exceeding - Finds and fixes problems before they are reported. - Proposes practical solutions backed by evidence. - Takes ownership of difficult issues and sees them through. - Improves processes in ways that save the team time. Meeting - Solves routine problems independently. - Escalates the right issues at the right time. - Uses data and evidence to support decisions. - Looks for ways to improve how the team works. Developing - Could try a solution before escalating routine issues. - Would benefit from looking at the cause, not just the immediate problem. - Should bring a suggested option when raising a problem. - Is building confidence to make decisions within their remit.

Leadership and management

When to use it: Comments for people who manage others or lead projects.

Exceeding - Sets clear goals and gives the team the context to meet them. - Develops people: several team members have taken on bigger roles. - Gives timely, specific feedback, both positive and constructive. - Makes difficult decisions and explains the reasons. Meeting - Holds regular 1:1s and keeps the team informed. - Delegates work appropriately. - Deals with performance issues promptly and fairly. - Represents the team's needs to senior leaders. Developing - Could delegate more, to free time for planning. - Would benefit from giving feedback closer to the event. - Should involve the team earlier in planning. - Is learning to address performance concerns directly.

Attendance, reliability and adaptability

When to use it: Comments on dependability and coping with change. Take care with absence: health and caring reasons may be protected.

Strong - Is consistently reliable; the team knows they can depend on them. - Adapts quickly when priorities change and helps others adjust. - Stays positive and practical during busy periods. - Learns new systems quickly and helps others learn them. Meeting - Follows the absence reporting procedure. - Manages time well and is ready for shifts and meetings. - Accepts changes and asks questions to understand them. Developing - Needs to give more notice when changing plans that affect colleagues. - Would benefit from asking for help sooner when struggling with change. - Before writing about attendance, check whether absence relates to health, disability, pregnancy or caring responsibilities, and follow your policy and local law.

How to use this template

  • 1Choose a phrase as a starting point, then add a real example and its effect using the formula.
  • 2Balance strengths and development areas, and make development comments specific and actionable.
  • 3Use the same standard of evidence for everyone in the team.
  • 4Avoid phrases about personality, age, appearance or personal life.
  • 5Read the full review back before sharing it: does it sound like this person, or like anyone?

Mistakes to avoid

  • Copying phrases without examples, so every review reads the same.
  • Vague praise such as "great job" or "team player" with no evidence.
  • Words that tend to be applied unevenly, such as "abrasive" or "too emotional".
  • Development comments with no suggestion of what to do next.
  • Commenting on absence that may relate to health, disability or caring without considering the law and your policy.

Questions

What are good performance review phrases?

Phrases that describe observable work or behaviour, such as "explains complex topics clearly to non-specialists", followed by a specific example and its effect.

How do I write appraisal comments?

Use the formula: phrase, specific example, effect, next step. Base each comment on evidence from the whole review period.

What should I write for areas of improvement?

Describe the gap with an example and suggest a concrete next step, such as "Could share bad news earlier: in Q3 a delay was flagged on the deadline day. Next period, raise risks in our weekly 1:1."

How do I avoid bias in performance reviews?

Use the same criteria and standard of evidence for everyone, look at the whole period, focus on work and behaviour rather than personality, and check whether you would write the same about someone else with the same evidence.

Can I use these phrases in a self appraisal?

Yes. Employees can use them as prompts, adding their own examples.

For hiring teams

Before this form goes out, see who can do the work

Cohesyve takes a job description, finds candidates, reaches out to them and runs an AI job simulation of the real work, then returns a ranked shortlist.

1,500+

assessments completed

50%

faster time-to-hire

5 min

from JD to assessment

14-day free trial · 10 candidates · Not charged until the trial ends

See Cohesyve in action

Free 30-min walkthrough

See it on your role