Recruiting template

Performance Review Template

A performance review is a structured conversation, with a written record, about how an employee has performed against their objectives and role expectations, and what comes next. Use the annual review form below, or the shorter quarterly and probation versions, and send the self-appraisal to the employee beforehand.

Performance Review Template

Fill in your details

Every version below updates as you type. A field left empty stays as a [placeholder] in the text you copy.

Your company and sender details are remembered, so the next template starts with them filled in.

Annual performance review form

When to use it: The main annual or half-year review against objectives and role expectations.

Performance review: [Employee name], [Job title] [Company name] | Period: [Review period] | Reviewer: [Reviewer] | Meeting: [Review meeting date] Rating scale 1 Not yet meeting expectations | 2 Partly meeting | 3 Meeting | 4 Exceeding | 5 Far exceeding Section 1: Objectives Objective | Result and evidence | Employee rating | Manager rating 1. [ ] | [ ] | [ ] | [ ] 2. [ ] | [ ] | [ ] | [ ] 3. [ ] | [ ] | [ ] | [ ] Section 2: Role expectations and behaviours Area | Evidence (specific examples) | Rating Quality of work | [ ] | [ ] Productivity and reliability | [ ] | [ ] Communication | [ ] | [ ] Teamwork and collaboration | [ ] | [ ] Problem solving | [ ] | [ ] [Company value] | [ ] | [ ] Section 3: Summary Key strengths: [ ] Areas to develop: [ ] Overall rating: [ ] Section 4: Looking ahead Objectives for the next period (SMART): 1. [ ] 2. [ ] 3. [ ] Development plan: [ ] Support from manager: [ ] Section 5: Employee comments [ ] Signatures (confirms the discussion took place) Employee: ____________ Date: ______ Manager: ____________ Date: ______

Quarterly performance check-in

When to use it: A lighter review between annual reviews.

Quarterly check-in: [Employee name], Q[ ] Reviewer: [Reviewer] | Date: [ ] 1. Progress on objectives Objective | On track / At risk / Done | Notes [ ] | [ ] | [ ] 2. What went well this quarter? [ ] 3. What was difficult, and what would help? [ ] 4. Priorities for next quarter - [ ] - [ ] 5. Development progress [ ] 6. Anything else either of us wants to raise? [ ]

Probation review form

When to use it: Reviewing a new employee before the end of probation.

Probation review: [Employee name], [Job title] Probation ends: [Probation end date] | Reviewer: [Reviewer] | Date: [ ] Area | Meeting the standard? (Yes / Not yet) | Evidence Learning the role and systems | [ ] | [ ] Quality of work | [ ] | [ ] Reliability and attendance | [ ] | [ ] Working with the team | [ ] | [ ] Following policies and procedures | [ ] | [ ] Support given during probation: [ ] Employee comments: [ ] Outcome [ ] Probation passed: employment confirmed [ ] Probation extended to [date] (only if your contract or policy allows), with these objectives: [ ] [ ] Probation not passed: [follow your procedure and take advice] Signed (manager): ____________ Signed (employee): ____________

Manager preparation guide

When to use it: Preparing for a review meeting so it is fair and useful.

Before the meeting - Send [Employee name] the self-appraisal at least a week before. - Look at evidence from the whole period, not just the last few weeks: objectives, 1:1 notes, feedback from colleagues and customers, and work samples. - Note specific examples for each rating. - Check for bias: are you rating the person or the work? Would you rate someone else the same for the same evidence? - Draft objectives for the next period. In the meeting - Start with the employee's view of the period. - Discuss strengths before development areas, with examples for both. - Agree, don't announce, next period's objectives. - Ask what support they need from you. - Leave time for their questions and comments. After the meeting - Finalise the form, share it and give them time to add comments. - Put follow-up dates in the diary.

How to use this template

  • 1Set objectives at the start of the period, so the review measures against something agreed.
  • 2Send the self-appraisal to the employee in advance and read it before the meeting.
  • 3Base every rating on specific evidence from the whole period.
  • 4Hold the review as a conversation; nothing important should be a surprise if you have held regular 1:1s.
  • 5Agree next period's objectives and development plan before you finish.

Mistakes to avoid

  • Rating on the last few weeks only (recency bias).
  • Ratings with no examples, which feel arbitrary and are hard to defend.
  • Raising a serious problem for the first time in the annual review.
  • Letting one strength or weakness colour every rating.
  • Filling in the form and never looking at it again.

Questions

What is a performance review?

A periodic, structured assessment of an employee's performance against their objectives and role expectations, usually with a meeting and a written record, and objectives for the next period. It is also called an appraisal or employee evaluation.

What should be included in a performance review?

Results against objectives, performance against role expectations and behaviours with examples, strengths, development areas, an overall rating if you use one, objectives and a development plan for the next period, and the employee's comments.

How often should performance reviews take place?

Many organisations hold a formal review once or twice a year with lighter quarterly check-ins and regular 1:1s in between.

What is an employee evaluation form?

The written form used to record a performance review, such as the annual form above, with ratings, evidence and comments.

What are good performance review examples?

Good reviews tie each comment to a specific example and its effect, such as "Rewrote the onboarding guide, which new starters now use in their first week." See our performance review phrases for wording by area.

For hiring teams

Before this form goes out, see who can do the work

Cohesyve takes a job description, finds candidates, reaches out to them and runs an AI job simulation of the real work, then returns a ranked shortlist.

1,500+

assessments completed

50%

faster time-to-hire

5 min

from JD to assessment

14-day free trial · 10 candidates · Not charged until the trial ends

See Cohesyve in action

Free 30-min walkthrough

See it on your role