Hiring guide

How to Hire a Paralegal

Where to find paralegals, NALA, NFPA and NALS credentials, research and discovery skills to test, a case file work sample, red flags and onboarding.

How to Hire a Paralegal

The short answer

Hiring a Paralegal comes down to verifying legal research in westlaw or lexis, with accurate citation checking, discovery management and e-discovery review in platforms such as relativity or everlaw and drafting first versions of pleadings, discovery requests, contracts or forms in your practice area before you commit interview time. The process below runs 5 stages, screens on evidence rather than résumé claims, and scores every candidate against the same criteria.

  • Watch for: Comfortable giving clients legal opinions, which risks unauthorised practice of law
  • Watch for: Claims a credential that does not appear in the issuing body's records
  • Score on: Accuracy and completeness of the chronology
  • Score on: Judgement in flagging privileged and sensitive documents
For hiring teams

Paste your Paralegal job description; Cohesyve finds, contacts and tests candidates on the real work and ranks them. 14-day free trial for 10 candidates, not charged until it ends.

Applying for a role like this? Practise the assessment free →

When you hire a paralegal, match the candidate to the practice area first: litigation, corporate, real estate, family, immigration and personal injury paralegals do very different work. All of them do substantive legal work under a lawyer's supervision, such as drafting, research, discovery and case management, and none of them can give legal advice or represent clients where the law does not allow it. This guide covers where to find paralegals, credentials worth checking, the skills to test, a case file work sample, red flags and onboarding.

Why this role matters

A good paralegal multiplies a lawyer's capacity. They organise discovery, prepare chronologies and exhibits, draft first versions of documents, manage filings and keep clients informed on process. Because their work feeds directly into advice and court filings, accuracy and judgement about when to escalate matter as much as speed. A weak paralegal pushes work back to lawyers or, worse, lets errors through.

Where to find candidates

  • NALA (the Paralegal Association) and holders of its Certified Paralegal (CP) and Advanced Certified Paralegal (ACP) credentials
  • NFPA (National Federation of Paralegal Associations) and its local associations, whose members may hold the RP or CRP credential
  • NALS and holders of its Professional Paralegal (PP) certification
  • Graduates of ABA-approved paralegal programmes, many of which run internships with local firms
  • Legal staffing agencies and bar association job boards
  • In the UK, CILEx members and paralegals on the Professional Paralegal Register or registered with NALP

Skills to look for

Legal research in Westlaw or Lexis, with accurate citation checkingDiscovery management and e-discovery review in platforms such as Relativity or EverlawDrafting first versions of pleadings, discovery requests, contracts or forms in your practice areaBuilding chronologies, exhibit lists, privilege logs and trial bindersCourt rules and e-filing for your jurisdictionsCase and matter management in tools such as Clio, plus disciplined time recordingClear client communication on process, without straying into legal advicePractice-area knowledge, such as closing checklists for real estate or form preparation for immigration

Red flags

  • Comfortable giving clients legal opinions, which risks unauthorised practice of law
  • Claims a credential that does not appear in the issuing body's records
  • Cannot explain how they check citations or confirm a document is the final version
  • No method for spotting privileged material during document review
  • Vague about the matters they worked on even at a non-confidential level
  • Writing sample with errors they did not catch

The interview process

  1. 1

    Screen

    Confirm practice area, matter types, software and court systems. Ask for a redacted or self-written writing sample.

  2. 2

    Interview with the supervising lawyer

    Discuss a matter they supported from start to finish: what they drafted, what they found and where they escalated. Ask about a mistake they caught.

  3. 3

    Case file work sample

    Give a small set of documents, emails and a pleading. Ask for a chronology of key events, a list of documents that look privileged and a short memo flagging issues for the lawyer. A job simulation of real paralegal work is one option if you are comparing several candidates.

  4. 4

    Team interview

    Have them meet the lawyers and paralegals they would support to judge working style and workload habits.

  5. 5

    References and checks

    Speak to a supervising lawyer about accuracy, judgement and discretion. Verify credentials with NALA, NFPA or NALS and run your conflict and background checks.

For hiring teams

Start the Paralegal interviews from a ranked shortlist

Cohesyve takes your Paralegal job description, finds and contacts candidates and tests each one on an AI job simulation of the job, so the stages above start with people who have already done the work. 14-day free trial for 10 candidates, not charged until it ends.

How to evaluate

  • Accuracy and completeness of the chronology
  • Judgement in flagging privileged and sensitive documents
  • Clarity of the memo to the lawyer
  • Depth of practice-area knowledge and court procedure
  • Understanding of the line between support and legal advice
  • References on reliability under deadline

Onboarding

  • 1Assign them to one or two lawyers at first so expectations are consistent
  • 2Share your templates, precedent bank and citation style
  • 3Set access permissions in document, e-discovery and billing systems by matter
  • 4Review their first drafts and filings in detail and give written feedback
  • 5Agree a continuing education plan, which also keeps any credential current

Common questions

Does a paralegal need to be certified?

In most US states certification is voluntary, though some states run their own programmes. NALA's CP, NFPA's RP or CRP and NALS's PP show tested knowledge. Practical experience in your practice area still matters most.

What can a paralegal not do?

In general, paralegals cannot give legal advice, set fees, accept cases or represent clients in court, except where a specific law allows it. The supervising lawyer remains responsible for their work.

How do I test a paralegal's skills?

Use a small, realistic case file and ask for a chronology, a privilege flag list and a short issues memo. This shows accuracy, judgement and writing in one task.

Should I hire a generalist or a specialist paralegal?

Small firms with mixed work often benefit from a generalist. If most of your work is in one area with its own procedures, such as immigration or e-discovery-heavy litigation, a specialist will be productive sooner.

For hiring teams

Hiring a Paralegal? Start with a ranked shortlist

Cohesyve takes your Paralegal job description, finds candidates, reaches out to them and runs an AI job simulation of the real work, then ranks them for you.

1,500+

assessments completed

50%

faster time-to-hire

5 min

from JD to assessment

14-day free trial · 10 candidates · Not charged until the trial ends

See Cohesyve in action

Free 30-min walkthrough

See it on your role