Hire by role

Hire Top Marketers

How to hire marketers: generalist or specialist, the skills to test, sample work tasks, where to find them and how to get a ranked shortlist.

Hire Top Marketers

The short answer

To hire marketers who can do the job, test audience understanding, positioning and messaging and writing on a realistic task before you interview, and score every candidate against the same rubric. Look beyond applicants: many strong marketers are employed and have to be approached.

  • Set a task: Write a one-page campaign brief for a product launch you describe, covering audience, message, channels, how a stated budget would be split and how success would be measured
  • Set a task: Audit one of your landing pages and list the changes they would make in order of importance, with a reason for each
  • Avoid: advertising for a marketer without deciding whether the job is a generalist's or a specialist's
  • Avoid: hiring a senior strategist when you need someone to do the work with their own hands, or the reverse
For hiring teams

Paste your job description; Cohesyve finds, contacts and tests marketers on the real work and ranks them. 14-day free trial for 10 candidates, not charged until it ends.

To hire a good marketer, decide first whether you need a generalist or a specialist, then test candidates on the work that role involves before you interview them. Give each one the same realistic task, such as writing a campaign brief for a product launch or auditing a landing page and listing what they would change, and mark the results against one rubric. Marketing résumés are full of campaigns the candidate was near, and it is hard to tell from the page what they did themselves. A work sample shows how they think about an audience, a message and a result. This page covers which kind of marketer to hire, what to test, what to expect at each level, where good marketers are found and how Cohesyve finds and tests them for you.

What does a Marketer do?

A marketer brings the right people to your product and gives them a reason to buy. The work falls into two kinds of role. A generalist, often titled marketing manager, plans campaigns across channels, writes or commissions the content, manages the budget, runs the website and email programme and reports on what worked. A specialist goes deep in one area: paid advertising, search engine optimisation, content, email and lifecycle, product marketing, brand or events. A small company with no marketing function usually needs a generalist who can do a bit of everything and buy in the rest. A company with one channel already working, or a clear gap such as positioning, gets more from a specialist. The nearest neighbour is the salesperson. Marketing creates demand and shapes how the market sees you across many people at once; sales turns individual buyers into customers one conversation at a time.

When do you need to hire a Marketer?

  • Growth depends on the founder's network and referrals, and both are running out
  • The sales team says it does not have enough good leads, or the leads it gets are the wrong kind
  • You are spending on advertising or agencies and nobody inside the business can judge whether it is working
  • A launch, a new market or a new product is coming and nobody owns the plan
  • Your website, emails and sales material describe the product in different and conflicting ways
  • One channel is clearly working and needs a specialist to grow it properly

What skills should you test marketers on?

SkillWhy it matters
Audience understandingEverything else rests on knowing who the buyer is and what they care about. Ask candidates to describe your customer back to you from your website and see how close they get.
Positioning and messagingA marketer should be able to say what you sell, for whom and why it is different, in words a customer would use.
WritingBriefs, emails, pages and adverts are all writing. Clear, specific copy is the most reliable sign of a clear marketing mind, in specialists as well as generalists.
Campaign planningTurning a goal into an audience, a message, channels, a budget and a measure of success is the generalist's main job. A written brief shows it directly.
Channel skillFor a specialist, test the channel itself: an account structure in Google Ads, a keyword and content plan, an email sequence. For a generalist, test whether they know what good looks like in each.
Reading dataA marketer must look at a channel report or Google Analytics and decide what to do next. Look for conclusions the data supports and honesty about what it cannot show.
Budget judgementDeciding where to spend, and where to stop spending, matters more than any one campaign. Ask for the reasoning as well as the answer.
Working with sales and productMarketing that ignores what sales hears from buyers, or what the product can do, wastes money. Ask how they have worked with both.
Managing agencies and freelancersMost marketers buy in design, video or media buying. Writing a clear brief and judging the work that comes back is a skill in itself.

What to expect at each level

LevelWhat to expect
JuniorA marketing executive or coordinator who carries out defined tasks well: scheduling emails and social posts, updating web pages, pulling reports and drafting copy for review.
Mid-levelRuns campaigns or a channel from brief to report, manages a budget and outside suppliers, and recommends changes based on results. A specialist at this level is fully productive in their channel through tools such as Google Ads, HubSpot or Mailchimp.
SeniorOwns the marketing plan or a major function, sets positioning, decides how the budget is split across channels and is accountable for the results to the leadership team.
LeadA head of marketing who sets strategy, builds and manages the team and agencies, agrees targets with sales and reports to the chief executive or the board.

Work samples that show a good Marketer

Tasks you could set before the interview, and what each one shows.

TaskWhat it shows
Write a one-page campaign brief for a product launch you describe, covering audience, message, channels, how a stated budget would be split and how success would be measuredPlanning, prioritising and whether the plan fits the audience or is a generic list of channels.
Audit one of your landing pages and list the changes they would make in order of importance, with a reason for eachUnderstanding of the visitor, of messaging and of what makes someone act.
Read a channel performance report you provide and recommend where to move budget, using only the figures in the report and stating what further data they would wantAnalytical judgement and honesty about the limits of the data.
Rewrite your homepage headline and opening paragraph for a named customer segment, and explain the choicesPositioning and copywriting.
Write the brief they would send to a freelance designer or an agency for one piece of the launch campaignWhether they can direct other people's work clearly, which most marketing jobs require.
For hiring teams

Get a ranked shortlist of marketers

Give Cohesyve your job description. It finds marketers, including people who have not applied, reaches out to them and tests each one on an AI job simulation of the real work, then ranks them for you. 14-day free trial for 10 candidates, not charged until it ends.

Where do you find good marketers?

  • Marketers at companies that sell to the same audience as you, found through LinkedIn and approached directly
  • Agency staff who have run campaigns for businesses like yours and want to work for one company
  • People with public work: newsletters, articles and campaigns you have noticed yourself
  • Specialists in neighbouring roles, such as content writers or analysts, who are ready for a broader marketing job
  • Marketing communities, meetups and members of professional bodies such as CIM
  • Referrals from your sales team, your agencies and marketers you already know
  • Marketing job boards and your own careers page, for people actively looking

Ways to hire marketers

RouteSuitsTrade-off
Your own recruitingTeams with a recruiter and time to source, screen and testYou see only who applies or who you find, and screening is manual
Freelance marketplacesShort projects and work with a clear endYou are buying hours from a contractor, so it does not build a team
Staffing and recruitment agenciesUrgent or specialist roles where you want someone else to run the searchFees are tied to the hire, and the vetting is usually an interview with the agency
CohesyveTeams that want marketers sourced and tested on the real work before the first interviewYou still run the final interviews and make the offer yourself

How Cohesyve helps you hire marketers

  1. 1

    You share the job description

    Paste the description for the Marketer role you are hiring for.

  2. 2

    Cohesyve finds and contacts candidates

    It sources marketers, including people who have not applied, and reaches out to them.

  3. 3

    Every candidate does the work

    Each one takes an AI job simulation of the role's real work, scored against one rubric.

  4. 4

    You get a ranked shortlist

    You interview the people at the top of it and hire directly.

Mistakes to avoid when hiring marketers

  • Advertising for a marketer without deciding whether the job is a generalist's or a specialist's
  • Hiring a senior strategist when you need someone to do the work with their own hands, or the reverse
  • Accepting credit for a company's growth without asking what the candidate personally did
  • Expecting one hire to be expert in advertising, search, content, design, events and analytics together
  • Judging the work sample on polish and presentation over the quality of the thinking
  • Skipping the writing test for a role that is mostly written communication
  • Setting no measurable goal for the role, so that neither you nor the new hire can tell whether it is working

Interview questions for marketers

QuestionWhat to listen for
Tell me about a campaign you ran. What was the goal, what did you do yourself and what happened?A clear goal set in advance, their own tasks separated from the team's and a result they can explain.
Describe a campaign or channel that did not work. How did you know and what did you do?A measure they were watching, a decision to stop or change course and a lesson they applied afterwards.
If you joined us with a small budget, how would you decide where to spend it?Questions about your customers and current results before any answer, then a small number of tests with a way of judging them.
How would you describe our product to one of our customers?Evidence they have studied your website and market, and language a buyer would recognise.
How have you worked with a sales team?Regular contact, agreed definitions of a good lead and changes made because of what sales reported.

Common questions

How do I know a marketer is good before I interview them?

Ask for a short piece of real marketing work, such as a campaign brief or a landing page audit, and mark it against a rubric written in advance. Look at the reasoning: who the audience is, why this message and how success would be measured. That shows more than a list of past campaigns.

Should I hire a generalist marketer or a specialist?

Hire a generalist when you have no marketing function and need someone to plan, write, run several channels and manage suppliers. Hire a specialist when one channel or one problem matters most, for example paid advertising that already brings customers, or a product nobody can explain clearly. If you are unsure, a generalist is usually the safer first hire.

What should my first marketing hire be?

For most small companies, a hands-on generalist at mid-level or above who can write well, run campaigns personally and read the results. A very senior strategist with nobody to carry out the plan, or a junior hire with nobody to direct them, tends to disappoint.

Should I hire a marketer or use an agency?

An agency supplies specialist skill and extra hands for defined work such as media buying or design. An employed marketer knows your customers and product, sets the direction and judges what agencies produce. Many companies use both, and an agency works best when someone inside the business is briefing and managing it.

How does Cohesyve help me hire marketers?

You give Cohesyve the job description. It sources marketers, including people who have not applied, reaches out to them, and puts each one through an AI job simulation of the role's real work. You get one ranked shortlist to interview. Plans start at $199 a month billed annually, with a 14-day free trial for 10 candidates.

Is Cohesyve a freelance marketplace or a staffing agency?

Neither. Cohesyve does not employ the marketers or bill their hours. It finds and tests candidates for a role you are hiring for, and you hire the person directly.

For hiring teams

Hire marketers who have already done the work

Cohesyve takes your job description, finds marketers, reaches out to them and runs an AI job simulation of the real work, then returns one ranked shortlist to interview.

1,500+

assessments completed

50%

faster time-to-hire

5 min

from JD to assessment

14-day free trial · 10 candidates · Not charged until the trial ends

See Cohesyve in action

Free 30-min walkthrough

See it on your role