workplace investigation

Workplace Investigation: A Step-by-Step Guide for HR

·9 min read
Workplace Investigation: A Step-by-Step Guide for HR

The short answer

A workplace investigation is the fact-finding an employer does before deciding a disciplinary case, a grievance or a harassment complaint. It means agreeing the scope, appointing someone impartial, gathering evidence and interviewing the people involved, then writing a report that says which facts were and weren’t established, so a separate decision-maker can decide what happens next.

  • Write terms of reference first: what is being investigated, who reports to whom, and whether the investigator recommends an outcome.
  • Use someone with no involvement in the matter; for serious cases, someone more senior or an external investigator.
  • Gather evidence on both sides and record how you obtained it. The aim is to find out what happened, not to prove guilt.
  • Keep it confidential, protect people who take part from retaliation, and keep the report securely.

A workplace investigation is the process an employer uses to establish the facts before acting on a disciplinary issue, a grievance or a complaint such as bullying or harassment. An HR investigation gathers evidence from all sides, works out whether there's a case to answer, and gives the decision-maker a fair basis for what happens next. Acas puts it simply: the employer finds out "all they reasonably can about the issue".

Getting it wrong is costly. Acas warns that if an employer doesn't carry out a reasonable investigation, the decisions that follow are likely to be unfair. This guide is for HR managers, people leads and founders. Process advice is drawn mainly from Acas, and the legal notes are country-specific. This is general information, not legal advice.

When do you need a workplace investigation?

You need one whenever you may take disciplinary action, when an employee raises a formal grievance, and when someone reports harassment, bullying or discrimination. Some jurisdictions require it: in Ontario, employers must make sure a workplace harassment complaint is investigated in a way that is "appropriate in the circumstances".

The depth depends on the case. Acas says a simple case might take a day to gather enough information, and a complicated one could take several weeks. If the employee admits the facts, less investigation may be needed, though the reasons behind what happened may still need looking at.

The steps of an HR investigation

StepWhat you doOutput
1. Decide to investigateCheck whether the issue could be resolved informally, and what policy applies.A decision and a named owner
2. Scope and appointWrite terms of reference and appoint an impartial investigator.Terms of reference
3. PlanList the issues, witnesses, evidence sources and time limits.Investigation plan
4. Tell the people involvedExplain the process, unless that risks evidence being tampered with.Notification letters
5. Gather evidenceCollect documents, records and data, lawfully.Evidence log
6. InterviewMeet the person complained about, the complainant and witnesses.Signed statements
7. ReportSet out facts established, facts not established and mitigation.Investigation report
8. OutcomeA separate decision-maker decides on formal, informal or no further action.Outcome letters
For hiring teams

Hiring for a role right now?

Cohesyve takes a job description, finds candidates, reaches out to them and runs an AI job simulation of the real work, then returns a ranked shortlist. Ten candidates free, no card.

Who should investigate?

Choose someone with no involvement in the matter, such as another manager or someone from HR, so there's no conflict of interest. Acas suggests the investigator should ideally be trained and know your investigations policy, and that serious or complex cases (possible gross misconduct, discrimination or bullying) may call for someone more senior or experienced. In exceptional circumstances an external consultant can bring an independent view, at more cost and time.

In a disciplinary case, Acas recommends that, where possible, different people handle the investigation, the disciplinary hearing and any appeal. In a grievance, it's usually best for the person hearing the grievance to investigate it.

Workplace investigation plan checklist

Start with terms of reference agreed between the employer and the investigator. Acas says they should cover:

  • what needs to be investigated;
  • whether the investigator is expected to make recommendations;
  • how the findings should be set out;
  • who the findings go to.

Then build the investigation plan. Based on Acas guidance, it should list:

  • the issues or allegations, written as specific questions;
  • who is investigating, and who they report to;
  • the witnesses, and the order you'll speak to them in;
  • evidence sources: emails, documents, computer and phone records, attendance records, CCTV;
  • time limits, such as CCTV that gets overwritten or a witness going on leave;
  • the target timescale, and who tells the parties about any delay;
  • the policies that apply;
  • how confidentiality will be kept and what people will be told;
  • support for those involved, and any reasonable adjustments.

Acas publishes a free investigation plan template that follows the same headings.

Telling the employee and deciding on suspension

Tell the person under investigation as soon as you decide to investigate, unless there's a risk they might tamper with evidence or influence witnesses. Acas lists what to explain: why you're investigating, who's doing it, what will happen, that witnesses will be spoken to, how long it may take, and that an investigation meeting is only to establish the facts, not a disciplinary meeting.

Suspension is only needed in some situations. Consider the alternatives and the person's wellbeing first, because being suspended can be stressful and affect mental health. Under the Acas Code, suspension should be with pay, as brief as possible, kept under review, and not treated as disciplinary action.

Interviews: how to question the parties and witnesses

Interview the person under investigation early: it shows which facts are disputed, so you can focus the rest of the work. Before each meeting, confirm in writing the reason, date, time and place, and give reasonable notice.

At the start, explain who's present and why, the purpose, the need for confidentiality, and that the notes may become a witness statement used in the report.

During the meeting, ask neutral, non-confrontational questions, record answers and any refusals to answer, and look for evidence that supports what you hear.

At the end, ask if there's anything else they think matters and who else you should speak to, explain they may be interviewed again, and send them their notes to check and sign.

The right to be accompanied (UK). By law a worker can bring a companion to any grievance meeting, and to a disciplinary meeting that could result in a formal warning or other action. At a disciplinary investigation meeting there's no legal right, but Acas says it's good practice to allow it. For disabled workers, a reasonable adjustment may mean allowing someone else to attend.

Witnesses. Acas advises avoiding anonymous statements where possible, so the person under investigation can fairly question the evidence. Use anonymity only in exceptional cases, such as a genuine fear of reprisal, and explain that names might have to be shared if there are legal proceedings. If many people saw the same incident, you don't need to speak to all of them unless accounts differ significantly.

Recording meetings. Only with the policy allowing it and everyone agreeing. Acas notes that a covert recording might be treated as misconduct.

Evidence and confidentiality

Gather everything you reasonably can and need, on both sides. The investigator's job is to establish the facts, not to prove guilt. Follow data protection law and respect privacy. Acas says employers should make clear in advance if monitoring such as CCTV, vehicle trackers, computer, phone or email records may be used in investigations. Keep a written record of how and why you obtained each piece of evidence.

Searching someone's desk or locker should only happen in exceptional, clearly justified circumstances. Even where the contract allows it, consent is usually needed, and the worker should be invited to be present.

If a crime may have been committed, you can involve the police; if you continue your own investigation alongside criminal proceedings, take care not to influence them.

What goes in a workplace investigation report?

The report should state which facts were established, which were not, and any mitigating circumstances. Acas warns that leaving information out could make the investigation unfair, and that the conclusions should be the investigator's own, even if HR advises.

Report outline

  1. Terms of reference and who appointed the investigator.
  2. Background: the complaint or concern and the policy it falls under.
  3. Method: who was interviewed, when, and what evidence was reviewed (with the evidence log as an appendix).
  4. Each allegation in turn: the evidence for and against, and an assessment of how reliable it is.
  5. Findings: facts established, facts not established, and mitigating circumstances.
  6. Recommendations, only if the terms of reference ask for them: formal action, informal action or no further action.
  7. Appendices: signed statements, documents and a note of any delays and why.

Write it plainly and objectively, explain any acronyms, and keep to the facts. The investigator shouldn't discuss possible sanctions, and if they attend a later hearing, it's to give facts, not to argue the case.

What happens after the investigation?

The employer reviews the report and decides whether there's a case to answer. Acas lists the options:

  • Formal action: a disciplinary hearing, changes to policy or procedure, or a further investigation into other matters found.
  • Informal action: training or coaching, counselling, mediation, or a note that similar behaviour could lead to disciplinary action.
  • No further action: tell the worker, and consider support such as mediation or counselling.

Keep the report securely, limit access, and dispose of it securely when it's no longer needed. In the UK, workers can ask for information their employer holds about them under UK GDPR, and anyone named in a report can see the parts about them or based on what they said, with other people's private information removed or redacted. Anonymised complaint data is also worth reviewing over time; our guide to HR data analytics covers how to track patterns.

Country notes for workplace investigations

CountryWhat the law or regulator expects
UKInvestigations are covered by the Acas Code of Practice; tribunals look at whether it was followed.
USNo single federal procedure. Employer liability for harassment turns on prompt corrective action, and taking part in an investigation is protected from retaliation.
Canada (Ontario)The written harassment program must say how complaints are investigated, how information stays confidential, and how both parties are told the results.
Canada (federal)Federally regulated employers must try to resolve every occurrence they're told about and keep records for 10 years.
AustraliaIn unfair dismissal claims, the Fair Work Commission considers whether the employee was told the reason and given an opportunity to respond.

United Kingdom. Acas says your own investigations policy should follow the Acas Code as a minimum. The Code mainly applies to employees, but Acas advises following the same fair procedure for all workers.

United States. The EEOC says an employer is liable for harassment by co-workers or non-employees it controls if it knew or should have known and didn't take prompt and appropriate corrective action. For a hostile environment created by a supervisor, the employer may avoid liability if it reasonably tried to prevent and promptly correct the behaviour. The EEOC's retaliation guidance lists answering questions in an employer's harassment investigation as protected activity. As of October 2026, there's no current EEOC enforcement guidance on harassment: the Commission voted on 22 January 2026 to rescind its 2024 guidance. The underlying laws still apply. See our examples of discrimination for the protected characteristics involved.

Canada. In Ontario, the Occupational Health and Safety Act requires a written workplace harassment program covering how incidents are reported (including a route if the alleged harasser is the employer or supervisor), how they're investigated, how information is kept confidential, and how the complainant and alleged harasser (if a worker) are told the results and any corrective action. Federally regulated employers are covered by the Work Place Harassment and Violence Prevention Regulations, in force since 1 January 2021.

Australia. Where an investigation could lead to dismissal, the Fair Work Act (section 387) asks whether there was a valid reason, whether the employee was told it, and whether they had an opportunity to respond. Treat the investigation as the place that opportunity starts.

This is general information, not legal advice. For serious allegations, or where criminal conduct may be involved, take legal advice before you start.

Sources

Checked 30 October 2026.

For hiring teams

Bring one open role and see who Cohesyve finds

Cohesyve takes a job description, finds candidates, reaches out to them and runs an AI job simulation of the real work, then returns a ranked shortlist. You see who can do the work before you spend interview time on anyone.

1,500+

assessments completed

50%

faster time-to-hire

5 min

from JD to assessment

No credit card · 10 free candidates · Plans sized to your hiring volume

For job seekers

Job hunting yourself? Practise on AI job simulations of the real work. 3 free tests, no card.

Show your next employer your best work →

See Cohesyve in action

Free 30-min walkthrough

See it on your role