big five personality test

Big Five Personality Test for Hiring: Traits and Evidence

·9 min read
Big Five Personality Test for Hiring: Traits and Evidence

The short answer

A Big Five personality test is a questionnaire that scores a person on five broad traits: openness to experience, conscientiousness, extraversion, agreeableness and neuroticism (OCEAN). For hiring, the research finds that conscientiousness predicts job performance across occupations, that the other traits matter only for particular jobs, and that the prediction is modest. Use it as one input beside a work sample and a structured interview, never as the deciding screen.

  • The five traits are scales. A candidate gets a position on each one, and there are no types.
  • Conscientiousness is the trait with the most consistent link to performance in the published meta-analyses.
  • Self-report answers can be shaped by candidates who want the job, so treat scores as prompts for questions.
  • In the US and UK, the employer answers for the test: check job relevance, group outcomes, health-related items and adjustments.
For job seekers

An AI job simulation of the real work, with a scored report. 3-day free trial, cancel anytime.

A Big Five personality test is a questionnaire that places a person on five broad trait scales: openness to experience, conscientiousness, extraversion, agreeableness and neuroticism. The US Office of Personnel Management (OPM) names the Big Five as the traits personality tests most commonly measure. For an employer, the short version is this: one trait, conscientiousness, has a consistent link to job performance, the link is modest, and the test works best as a supporting measure beside evidence of what the candidate can do.

This guide is written for people who hire. It covers what the five traits are, what the primary research says about using them in selection, where the method is weak, the legal care it needs in the US and UK, and how to combine it with a work sample.

What is the Big Five personality test?

It is any questionnaire built to measure the five trait dimensions of the Big Five model. The APA Dictionary of Psychology defines the model as "a model of the primary dimensions of individual differences in personality".

There is no single official test. Several publishers sell their own questionnaires, and the International Personality Item Pool (IPIP) publishes items and scales in the public domain. Its website says it holds over 3,000 items and over 250 scales that anyone can "copy, edit, translate, or use" without permission or a fee. So when a vendor says its product is "a Big Five test", ask which questionnaire it is and what evidence sits behind that version.

Candidates usually rate how far statements describe them. The output is a score on each scale, often shown against a comparison group. A person is placed somewhere along each scale. The model does not sort people into types.

What are the Big Five personality traits?

The five traits are openness to experience, conscientiousness, extraversion, agreeableness and neuroticism. The descriptions below follow the APA Dictionary of Psychology entries.

TraitWhat it describesOften reported as
Openness to experienceThe tendency to be open to new aesthetic, cultural or intellectual experiencesOpenness, curiosity
ConscientiousnessThe tendency to be organised, responsible and hardworkingDependability, drive
ExtraversionAn orientation towards the outer world of people and things. Extraverts are relatively outgoing, sociable and expressiveSociability, assertiveness
AgreeablenessThe tendency to act in a cooperative, unselfish mannerCooperation, consideration
NeuroticismEmotional instability and proneness to psychological distressEmotional stability (the scale reversed)

Hiring reports often flip neuroticism and call it emotional stability, so that a higher score reads as the calmer end. Check which direction a report uses before you read it.

For job seekers

Get used to being assessed before it counts

Run an AI job simulation of the real work and get a scored report on where you stand. 3-day free trial, cancel anytime.

What does OCEAN stand for, and is the five factor model the same thing?

OCEAN is an acronym for the five traits: Openness, Conscientiousness, Extraversion, Agreeableness, Neuroticism. An "OCEAN personality test" and a "Big 5 personality test" are the same kind of questionnaire.

The five factor model is a closely related name. The APA Dictionary lists the "Big Five personality model" and the "five-factor personality model" as separate entries with the same five dimensions. In hiring, the two terms are used for the same five traits.

What does the research say about the Big Five and job performance?

The published meta-analyses agree on one finding: conscientiousness predicts performance across jobs, and the other four traits predict it only in certain jobs or for certain outcomes. They also agree that the size of the prediction is modest.

SourceWhat it found
Barrick and Mount (1991), Personnel PsychologyConscientiousness "showed consistent relations with all job performance criteria for all occupational groups". Extraversion predicted performance for managers and sales. Openness and extraversion predicted training proficiency. Other relations were small (reported as ρ < .10).
Barrick, Mount and Judge (2001), International Journal of Selection and AssessmentA summary of 15 earlier meta-analyses. Conscientiousness was valid in all occupations studied. Emotional stability also generalised when overall work performance was the outcome. Extraversion, openness and agreeableness did not predict overall performance, though they predicted success in specific occupations or on specific criteria.
Morgeson and five co-authors (2007), Personnel PsychologyFive former journal editors concluded that the main issue is "the very low validity of personality tests for predicting job performance", and that the use of published self-report tests in selection "should be reconsidered".
Sackett, Zhang, Berry and Lievens (2022), Journal of Applied PsychologyEarlier validity estimates for selection methods in general were too high, by .10 to .20 points on average. Structured interviews came out as the top-ranked method. The authors still conclude that selection procedures "remain useful".

Read together, these papers support a narrow use. A Big Five measure adds some information about how a person tends to work. It is a weak basis for a decision when used alone.

OPM reaches the same practical view in its assessment guidance. It says personality tests "have been shown to be valid predictors of job performance" and that they "tend to be less valid than other types of predictors such as cognitive ability tests".

Which traits matter for which roles?

Conscientiousness is relevant to almost every job. For the other traits, relevance depends on what the job demands, so start from a job analysis and choose the traits you can tie to real duties.

The table is an illustrative starting point, based on the patterns in Barrick and Mount (1991). It is a prompt for your own job analysis and it is no substitute for one.

Role demandTrait to look atWhy (illustrative)
Any role with deadlines and unsupervised workConscientiousnessThe one trait with a consistent link to performance
Sales and people managementExtraversionLinked to performance in jobs built on social interaction
Roles with long training periodsOpenness, extraversionLinked to training proficiency
Roles with sustained pressureEmotional stabilityGeneralised for overall performance in the 2001 summary

Avoid building an "ideal profile" from the scores of your current top performers unless you have enough people and proper statistical help. A profile drawn from a handful of employees mostly describes those employees.

What are the limits of a Big Five test in hiring?

The main limits are modest prediction, answers that candidates can shape, and questions that can look unrelated to the job.

  • Modest prediction. The papers above are the evidence. A trait score explains a small part of who performs well.
  • Faking. Most tests are self-report. OPM warns that items can be "highly transparent, making it easy for applicants to fake or distort test scores in their favor". Morgeson and colleagues go further and say faking "cannot be avoided".
  • Candidate reaction. OPM notes that tests "may contain items that do not appear to be job related" and that applicants may see them as "unnecessarily invasive".
  • It measures tendency. A high conscientiousness score says a person describes themselves as organised. It does not show that they can write the code, close the sale or run the ward.
  • Version quality varies. A free quiz and a validated occupational questionnaire can both carry the Big Five label. Ask for the technical manual, the comparison groups and the validation evidence for jobs like yours.

One point in its favour: OPM reports that "few, if any, average score differences are found between men and women" on personality tests. That is no guarantee for your own process, so you still need to check your own results by group.

The employer is responsible for the test, even when a vendor supplies it. The rules below are for the United States and the United Kingdom only. Other countries have their own discrimination and data protection law, so check locally before you test candidates there. This is general information, not legal advice.

IssueUnited StatesUnited Kingdom
Group outcomesTitle VII bars neutral tests that disproportionately exclude people by race, colour, religion, sex or national origin unless they are job-related and consistent with business necessity (EEOC, "Employment Tests and Selection Procedures").Under section 19 of the Equality Act 2010, a practice that puts people with a protected characteristic at a particular disadvantage is indirect discrimination unless the employer can show it is a proportionate means of achieving a legitimate aim.
How outcomes are checkedThe Uniform Guidelines (29 CFR 1607.4(D)) treat a selection rate below four-fifths of the highest group's rate as general evidence of adverse impact.No numeric rule appears in section 19. The test is particular disadvantage and justification.
Health and disabilityUnder the ADA, no medical examinations before a conditional job offer. EEOC guidance says psychological examinations are medical "if they provide evidence that would lead to identifying a mental disorder".Section 60 of the Equality Act 2010 says an employer must not ask about an applicant's health before a job offer, with limited exceptions.
AdjustmentsThe EEOC says the ADA requires reasonable accommodations, "including in the administration of tests", unless they would impose an undue hardship.gov.uk says you must make adjustments to the recruitment process if they are reasonable, such as letting a candidate complete a written test on a computer.

Three practical steps follow from this.

  1. Use a questionnaire designed for work settings. Clinical instruments, or items that probe mental health, create risk under the ADA and under section 60. Read the items yourself before you buy.
  2. Keep your own evidence. The EEOC says employers should ensure tests are properly validated and that the employer remains responsible even when a vendor provides documentation. It also recommends checking whether an equally effective alternative with less adverse impact exists.
  3. Monitor results. Track pass rates by group for every stage that uses a cut-off, and review the stage if the rates diverge.

How do you use a Big Five test alongside a work sample?

Let the work sample carry the decision about ability, and use the personality measure to sharpen your interview questions. OPM says of work samples that performance on them "relates highly to performance on the job" and that applicants "often perceive work samples as being very fair". It also notes that they can be costly to develop and to administer.

A workable order, shown as an illustration:

  1. Job analysis. List the tasks and the behaviours the job needs. Pick at most two or three traits you can tie to them.
  2. Work sample first. Give every candidate the same job task, marked against a rubric. Our guide to what a work sample test is explains how to build one, and job simulations for hiring covers the simulated version.
  3. Personality questionnaire for those who pass. Fewer people take it, and nobody is rejected on personality before they have shown their work.
  4. Structured interview. Turn low or unusual scale scores into questions. For a low conscientiousness score, ask for a specific example of managing competing deadlines and score the answer against your rubric. See our structured interview guide.
  5. Decide on the combined evidence. Weight the work sample and interview most heavily. Record the reasons.

Avoid hard cut-off scores on a trait unless you have validation evidence for that cut-off in that job. A cut-off turns a modest predictor into a gate, and it is the point where adverse impact has to be measured.

Cohesyve, which publishes this guide, makes work simulations. It does not offer a personality test, so if you want both, the personality measure comes from a separate provider.

Big Five test for hiring: a short checklist

  • The traits you measure are tied to duties in the job analysis.
  • The questionnaire was built for occupational use and has a technical manual.
  • No item asks about health or mental health conditions.
  • Candidates are told what the test is for and how it will be used.
  • Adjustments are offered and the route to ask for one is clear.
  • Scores inform interview questions and are never the only reason for rejection.
  • Pass rates are monitored by group at each stage.
  • A work sample or simulation supplies the evidence of ability.

Frequently asked questions

Is the Big Five personality test valid for hiring?

It has some validity, mainly through conscientiousness. Barrick and Mount (1991) found that trait related to performance in every occupational group they studied. Later reviewers, including Morgeson and colleagues (2007), judged the validity of self-report personality tests to be very low for high-stakes selection. That supports using it as a secondary measure.

Can candidates fake a Big Five test?

Yes, to a degree. OPM's guidance says transparent items make it easy for applicants to distort scores in their favour. This is one reason to follow a score up in a structured interview and to avoid deciding on the score alone.

Which commercial tests are based on the Big Five?

Many occupational questionnaires say they draw on the five factor model. One example is covered in our guide to the Hogan Personality Inventory. For the wider method, see personality testing for hiring.

For job seekers

Practise being assessed before the real one

Cohesyve runs AI job simulations of the real work and gives you a scored report on where you lost marks. You see where you are strong, where you are not, and what to work on.

3 days

free trial

Unlimited

tests on Pro

Full

report on every test

Any

real job posting

3-day free trial · Then Pro $20/mo · Cancel anytime

For hiring teams

Hiring rather than job hunting? Cohesyve finds and contacts candidates from your job description, tests them on a simulation of the real work and ranks them.

Get a ranked shortlist →

Practise before it counts

3-day free trial

Start practising