difficult interview questions

Difficult Interview Questions: 15 Hard Ones, With Answers

·7 min read
Difficult Interview Questions: 15 Hard Ones, With Answers

The short answer

Difficult interview questions test honesty, self-awareness and composure more than knowledge. For each one, work out what the interviewer is really checking, prepare a short, true answer that ends on something positive, and practise it out loud. The hardest ones are about weaknesses, failure, gaps, why you left, conflict and salary.

  • Keep answers to about a minute; long answers to hard questions sound defensive.
  • Use STAR (situation, task, action, result) for “tell me about a time” questions.
  • Name a real weakness and what you’re doing about it.
  • It’s fine to pause and say “Let me think about that for a moment.”
For job seekers

Cohesyve, which publishes this guide, runs practice simulations of the real work in a role, with a scored report on where you lost marks. 3-day free trial, cancel anytime.

Difficult interview questions are the ones designed to see how you think when there's no easy answer: your weaknesses, a failure, a gap in your CV, why you left your last job. They're hard because there's no script, and because a bad answer can sound worse than the thing you're explaining.

Below are 15 hard interview questions, what the interviewer is really checking with each, and an example answer you can adapt. The example answers are illustrations. Replace the details with your own true story.

Why do interviewers ask hard interview questions?

To see three things a CV can't show:

  • Self-awareness: do you know your weak spots, and are you working on them?
  • Honesty: do you own mistakes, or blame others?
  • Composure: can you think clearly under pressure?

The 15 difficult interview questions at a glance

#QuestionWhat it really checks
1What's your greatest weakness?Self-awareness and growth
2Tell me about a time you failed.Ownership and learning
3Why did you leave your last job?Professionalism, no bitterness
4Why were you laid off?Whether it was about you, and how you've moved on
5Can you explain this gap in your CV?Honesty and readiness
6Why should we hire you over other candidates?Fit with the role's needs
7Tell me about a conflict with a colleague.Maturity and communication
8Tell me about a time you disagreed with your manager.Judgement and respect
9What would your last manager say about you?Honest self-view
10Aren't you overqualified for this role?Commitment and motivation
11Where do you see yourself in five years?Ambition that fits the role
12What are your salary expectations?Realism and research
13Describe a decision you regret.Reflection
14What questions do you have for us?Interest and preparation
15Brain-teasers and estimation questionsHow you structure a problem
For job seekers

Prepared the hard answers? Now prove the skills behind them

Practise a simulation of the real work in your target role and get a scored report you can talk through in interviews. 3-day free trial, cancel anytime.

1. What's your greatest weakness?

Pick a real weakness that won't stop you doing this job, show you know it, and say what you're doing about it.

Example: "I used to say yes to every request, and my own deadlines slipped. Now I check new requests against my priorities each morning and agree a date before I commit. I'm still working on it, but I haven't missed a deadline this year."

Avoid disguised strengths like "I'm a perfectionist". Interviewers hear it constantly.

2. Tell me about a time you failed.

Choose a real failure with a clear lesson, take responsibility, and spend most of the answer on what you changed. Structure it with the STAR method.

Example: "I launched an email campaign without testing the links, and a third of them were broken. I owned it with my manager, sent a correction within the hour, and built a pre-send checklist the team still uses."

3. Why did you leave your last job?

Keep it short, factual and forward-looking. Never criticise a former employer. Our guide to your reason for leaving a job has wordings for most situations.

Example: "I'd learned a lot in four years, but there was no route into the analytics work I wanted. This role is exactly that."

4. Why were you laid off?

Say it was a business decision, in one sentence, without apology, and then move to what you've done since.

Example: "The company closed its London office in a restructure, and my whole team's roles went. Since then I've finished a course in SQL and I'm looking for a role where I can use it."

For the full approach, see how to explain being laid off in an interview, and our guide to the difference between being laid off and fired.

5. Can you explain this gap in your CV?

Give the reason in a sentence, say what you did, and say why you're ready now. More examples in our employment gap guide.

Example: "I took a year out to care for a parent. During that time I kept my bookkeeping skills current with a course, and I'm now ready to return full time."

6. Why should we hire you over other candidates?

You don't know the other candidates, so don't compare. Match two or three of your strengths to the role's biggest needs, with proof.

Example: "You need someone who can take over the month-end close quickly. I've run it for three years at a similar-sized company, and I cut it from eight days to five."

7. Tell me about a conflict with a colleague.

Choose a work disagreement, not a personal feud. Show you listened, found common ground and kept the work moving.

Example: "A designer and I disagreed about a launch date. I asked what was driving her concern, which was testing time, and we agreed to launch to a smaller group first. It went out on time and the full launch followed a week later."

8. Tell me about a time you disagreed with your manager.

Show you raised it respectfully, with evidence, and accepted the decision if it went the other way.

Example: "My manager wanted to cut a training session to save time. I showed him the support tickets that came from untrained users, and we kept a shorter version. If he'd said no, I'd have gone with it and tracked the tickets."

9. What would your last manager say about you?

Give a balanced answer that would match a reference: two strengths and one thing they'd want you to keep working on. Our guide to reference check questions shows what employers ask referees.

10. Aren't you overqualified for this role?

Address the hidden worry (that you'll leave or be bored) directly. Our guide to being overqualified goes further.

Example: "I understand the concern. I'm applying because I want to do this work hands-on again, and I'm planning to stay. My experience means I'll be useful quickly."

11. Where do you see yourself in five years?

Show ambition that fits the role and the company. Talk about skills and responsibility, not job titles you'd take from your interviewer.

12. What are your salary expectations?

Research the market for the role and location first. Give a range you'd be happy with, or ask about the budgeted range before answering. If the employer has published a range, refer to it.

Example: "Based on similar roles locally, I'm looking for something in the range you've advertised. I'm flexible depending on the overall package."

13. Describe a decision you regret.

Similar to the failure question. Choose a real decision, explain what you'd do differently, and show the habit you've built since.

14. What questions do you have for us?

"No questions" can sound like low interest. Prepare three, such as: "What would success look like in the first three months?", "What's the biggest challenge facing the team?" and "How is performance reviewed?"

15. Brain-teasers and estimation questions

Questions like "How many coffee cups are sold in this city each day?" test how you structure a problem. Say your assumptions out loud, break the problem into parts, do simple arithmetic, and sanity-check the result. A clear method matters more than the number.

How do you answer difficult interview questions well?

  1. Pause before answering. A few seconds of thought is fine.
  2. Answer the question asked, then stop. Over-explaining sounds defensive.
  3. Be honest. Invented stories fall apart under follow-up questions.
  4. End on a positive: what you learned, changed or achieved.
  5. Practise out loud. Answers that sound fine in your head often run long when spoken. A mock interview with someone who'll give honest feedback is the best rehearsal.

What if a question is too personal?

Some questions about your private life aren't relevant to the job. You can steer back politely: "I'm not sure that's relevant to the role, but I'm happy to talk about how I'd handle the work." What counts as an unlawful question depends on the country, so if something feels wrong, look up your local employment rules.

Back up your answers with proof

Hard questions are easier when you have recent evidence of your skills to point to. Cohesyve, which publishes this guide, lets you practise simulations of the real work in your target role and get a scored report you can draw on in interviews. For a bank of other questions to practise, see our list of behavioural interview questions and situational interview questions.

FAQs

What is the hardest interview question?

For most people it's "What's your greatest weakness?" or "Tell me about a time you failed", because they ask you to criticise yourself. A real example plus what you've changed handles both.

How long should my answers be?

About a minute for most questions, up to two for a detailed STAR story. If the interviewer wants more, they'll ask.

Is it OK to say "I don't know"?

Yes, if you follow it with how you'd find out. Bluffing is usually obvious.

How do I stay calm during tough questions?

Prepare your answers to the 15 questions above, practise them aloud, and take a breath before you answer. Preparation is what makes calm possible.

Should I memorise my answers?

Memorise the key points, not the words. Word-for-word answers sound rehearsed and are hard to adapt to follow-up questions.

What questions should I never answer?

You don't have to share personal details that aren't relevant to the job. Redirect politely to your ability to do the work.

For job seekers

Prepared the hard answers? Now prove the skills behind them

Practise a simulation of the real work in your target role and get a scored report you can talk through in interviews. 3-day free trial, cancel anytime.

3 days

free trial

Unlimited

tests on Pro

Full

report on every test

Any

real job posting

3-day free trial · Then Pro $20/mo · Cancel anytime

For hiring teams

Interviewing candidates rather than being interviewed? Cohesyve finds and contacts candidates from your job description, tests them on a simulation of the real work and ranks them.

Test candidates beyond the hard questions →

Practise before it counts

3-day free trial

Start practising